United Methodist Church’s highest court upholds closure of historic Hispanic congregation

The Judicial Council, the highest judicial authority within The United Methodist Church, has upheld the closure of La Trinidad United Methodist Church in East Los Angeles, California. The decision concerns a historic Hispanic congregation whose closure followed a dispute involving church property, financial oversight and denominational governance.

The controversy involved a $3.3 million ground-lease agreement connected to the church property and an affordable senior housing development. Regional church authorities raised concerns about the handling of funds and invoked an emergency closure procedure in January 2026. The California-Pacific Annual Conference subsequently voted to close the congregation.

In Decision 1526, dated 16 November, the Judicial Council affirmed that the regional conference had followed the denomination’s rules. Importantly, the ruling concerns La Trinidad’s status as an organised United Methodist congregation; it does not mean that all Hispanic worship and ministry in the area have ceased. A successor ministry, Nueva Esperanza, continues to serve the community. The decision has raised questions about church property, local congregational autonomy and denominational authority.