The South Dakota Supreme Court has overturned a lower court’s decision in a financial dispute involving a church and one of its former pastors. The disagreement concerns a $300,000 cheque given by a church member to Pastor Mario Torres, who maintained that the money was intended as a personal gift rather than a donation to the congregation.
The dispute began in 2022 when a donor issued three separate cheques worth $300,000 each. One was made payable to the church, while the other two were initially left without named recipients. The church subsequently deposited the cheques into accounts belonging to its satellite congregations. Torres later transferred $223,000 from one of those accounts into his personal account, leading to legal action.
The Supreme Court ruled that the lower court had made an error by deciding the dispute without first resolving Torres’ fraud claim at trial. It reversed the earlier judgment and sent the matter back for further proceedings. The ruling does not establish that Torres legally owns the money; the underlying dispute remains unresolved. The case highlights the importance of clear financial records and transparent donation procedures in churches.




